""The first quarter was another great example of the strength and resiliency of the Casey's business model, as we were able to expand gross profit dollars while growing the store base."" - Darren Rebelez
Caseys General Stores, Inc. (CASY) - Q1 FY2025 Results Summary and Outlook: Strong Store Growth, Margin Management, and Fikes Integration Progress
Executive Summary
Casey’s delivered a solid start to FY2025 with 5.9% revenue growth and meaningful margin expansion across key inside categories, driven by stronger prepared foods, grocery and general merchandise cost management, and favorable operating leverage from higher store counts. Net income rose 6.5% YoY to $180.2 million and diluted EPS reached $4.83, up 7% YoY. The quarter featured a disciplined capital allocation stance: free cash flow of $180.8 million, operating cash flow of $281.4 million, and a leverage ratio of 1.5x, supported by liquidity of approximately $1.2 billion. Management underscored progress on the three-year strategic plan (store growth, accelerated food differential, and efficiency enhancements) and reiterated the pending Fikes acquisition with 198 CEFCO stores, targeting ~270 store growth for FY2025 and a path to ~2.0x leverage within 12 months post-close. The near-term headwinds include elevated cheese costs and integration-related One-time costs associated with the Fikes transaction, alongside ongoing macro consumer dynamics. Overall, Casey’s appears positioned to execute its growth and margin-acceleration agenda while maintaining strong cash generation and a prudent balance sheet.
Key Performance Indicators
Revenue
4.10B
QoQ: 13.83% | YoY:5.91%
Gross Profit
955.26M
23.31% margin
QoQ: 19.70% | YoY:8.83%
Operating Income
251.37M
QoQ: 98.43% | YoY:7.43%
Net Income
180.20M
QoQ: 107.08% | YoY:6.48%
EPS
4.86
QoQ: 106.81% | YoY:7.05%
Revenue Trend
Margin Analysis
Key Insights
Revenue: $4.0977 billion, up 5.9% YoY; QoQ up 13.83% (Q1 metrics). - Gross profit: $955.3 million, up 8.8% YoY; gross margin 23.3%. - Operating income: $251.4 million, up ~7.4% YoY; QoQ surge reflecting operating leverage (2Q+). - Net income: $180.2 million, up 6.5% YoY; net margin ~4.4%. - Diluted EPS: $4.83, up 7% YoY; non-diluted EPS $4.83. - EBITDA: $345.8 million, up 9.1% YoY. - Inside sales: $1.47 billion, up 7.6% YoY. - Prepared Food & Dispensed Beverage: $405 million, up 8.7% YoY. - Grocery & General Merchandise: $1.07 billion, up 7.2% YoY. - Fuel gallons sold: +8% YoY; fuel margin $0.407/gal. - Same-store sales: +2.3% (Q1) and +7.9% on a 2-year stack. - Store count: +138 stores versus prior year; FY2025 target store growth ~270 units (raised from 100). - Free cash flow: $180.8 million. - Leverage: 1.5x; liquidity roughly $1.2 billion. - Capex: $100.6 million in the quarter; total cash at period-end: ~$305 million.
Financial Highlights
- Revenue: $4.0977 billion, up 5.9% YoY; QoQ up 13.83% (Q1 metrics). - Gross profit: $955.3 million, up 8.8% YoY; gross margin 23.3%. - Operating income: $251.4 million, up ~7.4% YoY; QoQ surge reflecting operating leverage (2Q+). - Net income: $180.2 million, up 6.5% YoY; net margin ~4.4%. - Diluted EPS: $4.83, up 7% YoY; non-diluted EPS $4.83. - EBITDA: $345.8 million, up 9.1% YoY. - Inside sales: $1.47 billion, up 7.6% YoY. - Prepared Food & Dispensed Beverage: $405 million, up 8.7% YoY. - Grocery & General Merchandise: $1.07 billion, up 7.2% YoY. - Fuel gallons sold: +8% YoY; fuel margin $0.407/gal. - Same-store sales: +2.3% (Q1) and +7.9% on a 2-year stack. - Store count: +138 stores versus prior year; FY2025 target store growth ~270 units (raised from 100). - Free cash flow: $180.8 million. - Leverage: 1.5x; liquidity roughly $1.2 billion. - Capex: $100.6 million in the quarter; total cash at period-end: ~$305 million.
Income Statement
Metric
Value
YoY Change
QoQ Change
Revenue
4.10B
5.91%
13.83%
Gross Profit
955.26M
8.83%
19.70%
Operating Income
251.37M
7.43%
98.43%
Net Income
180.20M
6.48%
107.08%
EPS
4.86
7.05%
106.81%
Key Financial Ratios
currentRatio
0.84
grossProfitMargin
23.3%
operatingProfitMargin
6.13%
netProfitMargin
4.4%
returnOnAssets
2.77%
returnOnEquity
5.7%
debtEquityRatio
0.51
operatingCashFlowPerShare
$7.59
freeCashFlowPerShare
$4.87
dividendPayoutRatio
9.22%
priceToBookRatio
4.55
priceEarningsRatio
19.96
Net Income vs. Revenue
Expense Breakdown
Management Commentary
- Strategy and execution: Management highlighted progress on the three-year plan—accelerating store growth, expanding the food businesses, and driving operational efficiency. Darren Rebelez emphasized: “we continue to show that our three year strategic plan is credible and achievable” and noted the plan’s emphasis on store expansion, enhanced prepared foods, and margin discipline. Steve Bramlage stressed the quality of earnings and capital allocation, including liquidity of $1.2B and the near-term focus on deleveraging post-Fikes close. - Unit growth and synergies: The company raised its FY2025 store-growth target to ~270 units (from 100) and signaled that the Fikes/CEFCO acquisition would add scale, with $89M pro forma EBITDA for 2023 and a plan to reach ~2.0x leverage within 12 months after closing. Darren added that the first quarter marked the ninth consecutive quarterly reduction in same-store labor hours as part of ongoing efficiency efforts. - Consumer dynamics and pricing: Darren noted that three-quarters of guests earn above $50k, with higher-income consumers showing resilient purchasing patterns, while lower-income segments are modestly pulling back on basket size. Steve commented on cheese costs as a margin headwind and the company’s hedging position (roughly 25% hedged for cheese this year) and emphasized a broader focus on overall inside-margin profitability and cost management. - Operational and margin drivers: Prepared Food and Dispensed Beverage margins rose 10 bps to 58.3% with waste improvements; grocery/GM margins rose 130 bps to 35.4% driven by COG management; fuel margins stood at $0.407/gal, with a $4.8M benefit from RINs sales versus $15.4M in the prior-year quarter.
"The first quarter was another great example of the strength and resiliency of the Casey's business model, as we were able to expand gross profit dollars while growing the store base."
— Darren Rebelez
"We are not updating our previously communicated fiscal year guidance until after the Fikes transaction closes with the exception of our store growth target. We now expect store growth to be approximately 270 units for the fiscal year, and that's up from our previously disclosed 100 units."
— Darren Rebelez
Forward Guidance
- Store growth progression: FY2025 store addition target raised to ~270 stores, with a plan to reach ~500 stores over the three-year horizon (per Casey’s plan). The company expects to realize synergies from Fikes/CEFCO, including upgrading kitchens where applicable and integrating fuel logistics capabilities (Fuel 3.0 via upstream sourcing and a fuel terminal). - Leverage and capital allocation: Management indicated it will not repurchase shares until leverage approaches the long-term target of 2.0x; pro forma leverage at closing is expected to be ~2.4x, with deleveraging to ~2.0x within 12 months post-close. - Margin and cost management: Expect continued cost-of-goods management in Grocery/GM, ongoing efficiency programs (5S, digital production planning), and hedge-driven mitigation of cheese costs. - Risks and monitoring: Key risks include commodity cost volatility (notably cheese), integration risk from major acquisitions, and persistent macroeconomic pressures on consumer spend. Key factors for investors to monitor include the progress of Fikes/CEFCO integration, the pace of store openings/remodels, fuel price/margin dynamics, and the achievement of the 3-year plan targets.
Competitive Position
Company
Gross Margin
Operating Margin
Return on Equity
P/E Ratio
CASY Focus
23.31%
6.13%
5.70%
19.96%
ATR
29.30%
12.60%
3.54%
28.28%
CBRL
33.00%
0.84%
1.10%
53.87%
CBSH
1.02%
31.00%
3.83%
14.30%
CRI
47.60%
7.53%
4.52%
19.96%
Gross Profit Margin
Operating Profit Margin
Return on Equity
P/E Ratio Comparison
Investment Outlook
Caseys is pursuing a disciplined growth-and-margin expansion strategy anchored by a robust three-year plan, accretive M&A (Fikes/CEFCO), and a reshaped store footprint that should support higher inside sales and margin efficiency. The Q1 FY2025 results demonstrate solid top-line growth, 2.3% same-store sales, and meaningful margin gains driven by Prepared Foods and Grocery/GM cost management, alongside a strong cash flow profile. The key unlocks are the successful integration of Fikes/CEFCO, the realization of synergies (estimated pro forma EBITDA of $89M for 2023 on the Fikes assets), and the ramping of store openings toward the 500-store target over three years. However, near-term pressures include cheese-cost headwinds and one-time Fikes deal costs, which could temper near-term margin progression. The company’s balance sheet remains healthy with 1.5x leverage and $1.2B liquidity, supporting its stated objective to delever to ~2x within 12 months post-close. Given the combination of deleveraging capability, resilient cash generation, and leadership’s clear focus on integration and margin discipline, the investment case favors a constructive view, contingent on successful Fikes/CEFCO integration, continued food-margin progress, and stabilization of commodity costs. Key factors for investors to monitor include: progression of the Fikes/CEFCO integration and related CapEx (~$145M incremental for kitchen upgrades), the cadence of store openings (target ~270 in FY2025), cheese and other commodity cost trajectories, and any changes to guidance as the Fikes transaction closes.
Key Investment Factors
Growth Potential
Store expansion to ~270 units in FY2025 with an eventual target of ~500 stores over three years; Fikes/CEFCO integration to amplify footprint and drive synergies; upstream fuel procurement (Fuel 3.0) and a dedicated fuel terminal to improve supply security and margin.
Profitability Risk
Cheese price volatility and other commodity costs; integration and one-time deal costs related to Fikes; lottery revenue volatility; macro consumer weakness in lower-income segments; potential regulatory overtime rule impact.
Financial Position
Strong liquidity (~$1.2B), net debt ~$1.30B, leverage ~1.5x; solid free cash flow generation (~$180.8M); dividend maintained at $0.50; diversified revenue mix (inside sales, fuel, and non-fuel store items) supporting operating cash flow.
SWOT Analysis
Strengths
Large, fast-growing store base expansion trajectory (target ~270 FY2025, plan for ~500 stores in 3 years)
Dominant in-store value proposition with strong prepared foods and grocery/GM margin improvements
Significant cash generation and strong liquidity (+$1.2B available)
Balance sheet discipline with leverage ~1.5x and steady deleveraging post-Fikes close
Integrated fuel program evolution (Fuel 3.0) and a fuel terminal via Fikes to strengthen supply chain and margins
Private label contributions improving grocery margins (~100 bps+) and loyalty program leverage
Weaknesses
Commodity cost sensitivity (notably cheese) acting as margin headwind
One-time deal costs associated with large acquisitions
Near-term integration risk and execution risk for Fikes/CEFCO
Cyclicality of lottery-driven traffic in certain months affecting comps
High dependence on fuel margins and external fuel price volatility
Opportunities
Upside from accelerated store openings (target ~270 FY25, ~500 three-year plan)
Fuel supply chain optimization and potential cost savings from upstream procurement
Expansion of private label and tiered value offerings to sustain traffic growth
Strengthening loyalty program to drive repeat visits and higher basket size
Sustainability initiatives to improve brand perception and operating efficiency
Threats
Macro consumer pressure, particularly in lower-income segments
Caseys General Stores, Inc. (CASY) Q1 FY2026 Results Analysis — Strong Start to 3-Year Plan with Margin Expansion and Strategic Initiatives Driving ...
Caseys General Stores Inc (CASY) Q4 FY2025 Results Preview and Analysis: Record EPS, Largest Store Growth Year, Fikes CEFO Acquisition Enhances EBITDA...